Menu Expand

Cite JOURNAL ARTICLE

Style

Laidler, D. Mayer on Monetarısm: Comments from a British Point of View. Credit and Capital Markets – Kredit und Kapital, 9(1), 56-69. https://doi.org/10.3790/ccm.9.1.56
Laidler, David "Mayer on Monetarısm: Comments from a British Point of View" Credit and Capital Markets – Kredit und Kapital 9.1, 1976, 56-69. https://doi.org/10.3790/ccm.9.1.56
Laidler, David (1976): Mayer on Monetarısm: Comments from a British Point of View, in: Credit and Capital Markets – Kredit und Kapital, vol. 9, iss. 1, 56-69, [online] https://doi.org/10.3790/ccm.9.1.56

Format

Mayer on Monetarısm: Comments from a British Point of View

Laidler, David

Credit and Capital Markets – Kredit und Kapital, Vol. 9 (1976), Iss. 1 : pp. 56–69

Additional Information

Article Details

Laidler, David

References

  1. Boyer, R.: Optimal Dirty Floating, University of Western Ontario, mimeo 1975.  Google Scholar
  2. Brittan, S.: Second 'Thoughts on Full Employment Policy, Centre for Policy Studies, London, 1975.  Google Scholar
  3. Brunner, K. and Meltzer, A.H.: The Uses of Money, Money in the Theory of an Exchange Economy AER 61, 5 (1971), pp- 784 - 805.  Google Scholar
  4. Committee on the Working of the Monetary System; Report (The Radcliffe Report) London, HMSO, 1959.  Google Scholar
  5. Cross, R.B. and Laidler, D.E. W.: Inflation, Excess Demand, and Expectations in Fixed Exchange Rate Open Economies: Some Preliminary Evidence in Parkin, J.M. and Zis, G. (eds.) Inflation in the World Economy, Manchester, Manchester University Press, 1975.  Google Scholar
  6. Dornbusch, R.: Currency Depreciation, Hoarding, and Relative Prices JPE 81 (1973), pp. 843 - 915.  Google Scholar
  7. Duck, N.W., Parkin, J.M., Rose, D.E. and Zis, G.: The Determination of Rate of Change of Wages and Prices in the Fixed Exchange Rate World Economy: 1956 - 1970 in Parkin and Zis (eds.) op cit.  Google Scholar
  8. Friedman, M.: The Case for Flexible Exchange Rates in Essays in Positive Economics, Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1953.  Google Scholar
  9. Gray, M.R., Ward, R. and Zis, G.: World Demand for Money in Parkin and Zis (eds.) op cit.  Google Scholar
  10. Harrod, R. F.: The Issues: Five Views in Hinshaw, R. (ed.) Inflation as a Global Problem, London, John Hopkins Press, 1972.  Google Scholar
  11. Hicks, J. R.: The Crisis in Keynesian Economics, Oxford, Blackwell, 1974.  Google Scholar
  12. Hicks, J. R.: What ıs Wrong with Monetarism, Lloyds Bank Review, October 1975, pp. 1-13. House of Commons, 9th Report From the Expenditure Committee, Public Expenditure, Inflation and the Balance of Payments, London, HMSO, 1974. Johnson, H.G.: Inflation and the Monetarist Controversy, Amsterdam, North Holland, 1972.  Google Scholar
  13. Johnson, H. G.: The Monetary Approach to Balance on Payments Theory, in Johnson, H. G.: Further Essays in Monetary Economics, London, 1973.  Google Scholar
  14. Laidler, D. E. W.: Monetarist Policy Prescriptions and their Background, Manchester School 41, March 1973, pp. 59-71.  Google Scholar
  15. Laidler, D.E. W.: Alternative Explanations and Policies Towards Inflation: Tests on Data Drawn from Six Countries in Brunner, K. and Meltzer, A.H. (eds.) Proceedings of the Third Carnegie Mellon Rochester Conference on Economic Policy (forthcoming).  Google Scholar
  16. Laidler, D. E. W. and Nobay, A. R.: Some Current Issues Concerning the International Aspects of Inflation in Laidler, D., Essays on Money and Inflation, Manchester, Manchester University Press, 1975.  Google Scholar
  17. Mundell, R.: Monetary Theory: Inflation Interest and Growth in the World Economy, Pacific Palisades, California, 1971.  Google Scholar
  18. Mussa, M.: A Monetary Approach to Balance of Payments Analysıs, Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 6; August 1974, pp. 333 - 352.  Google Scholar
  19. Parkin, J. M.: The World Monetary System ın Transition, ANZAS Lecture, St. Lucia, University of Queensland Press, 1973.  Google Scholar
  20. Parkin, J. M., Richards, I. and Zis, G.: The Determination and Control of the World Money Supply nder Fixed Exchange Rates 1961 - 1971, Manchester School 43, September 1975.  Google Scholar
  21. Swoboda, A.K.: Gold, Dollars, Euro Dollars and the World Money Stock mimeo from the Institute of International Studies of the University of Geneva, 1975.  Google Scholar
  22. Wiles, P.: Cost Inflation and the State of Economic Theory, Economic Journal 83, June 1973, pp. 377 - 98.  Google Scholar
  23. Zis, G.: Inflation: An International Monetary Problem or National Social Phenomenon?, British Journal of International Studies 1 (2), 1975.  Google Scholar
  24. Zis, G.: Political Origins of the International Monetary Crisis, National Westminster Bank Quarterly Review, August 1975.  Google Scholar

Abstract

Mayer on Monetarism: Comments from a British Point of View

I have little to quarrel with in the substance of Mayer’s paper“. However, various aspects of monetarism receive different emphasis ın different countries. My comments view monetarism from a British point of view. First, it is argued that, whatever the monetarists’ judgements about the relative importance of unemployment and inflation as social problems may be, and however these judgements differ from their Keynesian opponents, there is no such difference of ethics in Britain. There is, however, a difference in analysıs. The British monetarist argues that inflation is to be combatted with aggregate demand management, particularly monetary, policies, while unemployment should be tackled mainly by microeconomic policies geared to increasing the efficiency of the labor market. By way of contrast British Keynesianism has it that demand management policies should be geared to pursuing an unemployment target, while micro policies, in the form of wage and price controls, should be the principal anti-inflation weapon. Second, because Britain is an open economy British economists must take a view about the international nature of inflationary problems. There is a distinctively monetarist viewpoint here. It sees inflation in a world of fixed exchange rates as being determined at the level of the world economy and the problem of inflation in any one national economy as being best analyzed in terms of a theory of the transmission of inflation between regions of the closed world economy. The factors that seem important in transmitting inflation between national economies are inflationary expectations formed about the behavior of the world price level and, of course, money flows transmitted through the balance of payments. Moreover the monetarist sees the key to achieving exchange rate stability as lying in the international coordination of domestic monetary policies, rather than in the institutional framework of the foreign exchange market.