Search and Rescue in the Central Mediterranean Sea: A Legal Analysis of the Recent Italian Practice
JOURNAL ARTICLE
Cite JOURNAL ARTICLE
Style
Format
Search and Rescue in the Central Mediterranean Sea: A Legal Analysis of the Recent Italian Practice
German Yearbook of International Law, Vol. 63 (2020), Iss. 1 : pp. 121–148
Additional Information
Article Details
Pricing
Author Details
Lorenzo Schiano die Pepe, Professor of EU Law and Jean Monnet Chair in International and European Law of the Sea, University of Genoa, Italy.
Abstract
The article tracks the most recent trends of Italian practice in the field of Search and Rescue operations in the Central Mediterranean Sea. It does so by focusing on the international and European legislation that constitutes the backdrop of such practice, the analysis of legislative and administrative measures that have been adopted by Italian authorities, and the most relevant domestic case law. The increasing role played by non-governmental organisations constitutes one of the main focuses of the discussion and particular attention is paid to the attempts that have been made to govern their operations also by the implementation, in 2017, of a dedicated ‘Code of Conduct’. The ‘closed ports’ policy operated by Italy and its enforcement vis-à-vis State as well as non-governmental organisation vessels is also scrutinised together with its impact on the doctrine of ‘Place of Safety’ which must be ensured to every migrant rescued at sea.
Table of Contents
| Section Title | Page | Action | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lorenzo Schiano di Pepe\nSearch and Rescue in the Central Mediterranean Sea: A Legal Analysis of the Recent Italian Practice | 121 | ||
| I. The International Legal Framework Relevant to SAR Activities in the Central Mediterranean Sea | 121 | ||
| II. SAR-Related Maritime Operations in the Central Mediterranean Sea: The Role of Italy Between Unilateral Action and European Union-Led Initiatives | 124 | ||
| A. Mare Nostrum | 124 | ||
| B. Frontex Joint Operations Triton and Themis | 125 | ||
| C. 2015 Developments: (i) Mare Sicuro, (ii) Continuous Loss of Life in the Mediterranean Sea and (iii) EUNAVFOR MED Operations Sophia and Irini | 128 | ||
| 1. Mare Sicuro | 128 | ||
| 2. The ‘Deadliest Disaster in the Mediterranean’ | 129 | ||
| 3. EUNAVFOR MED Operations Sophia and Irini | 121 | ||
| III. Non-Governmental Organisations as Providers of Search and Rescue Services | 121 | ||
| A. Non-Governmental Organisation Search and Rescue Practice and Analysis | 121 | ||
| B. Italy’s ‘Code of Conduct for NGOs Undertaking Activities in Migrants’ Rescue Operations at Sea’ of 2017 | 121 | ||
| IV. Italy’s ‘Closed Ports’ Policy and the Question of the Place of Safety | 121 | ||
| A. Italy’s ‘Closed Ports’: From Political Statements to Ministerial Directives to Actual Legislation | 121 | ||
| B. Italy’s ‘Closed Ports’ Policy in Practice and the Question of the ‘Place of Safety’ | 122 | ||
| 1. NGO Units: Open Arms and Sea-Watch 3 | 122 | ||
| 2. Military Units: Diciotti and Gregoretti | 122 | ||
| C. Covid-19 Pandemic, Migration by Sea, and SAR | 122 | ||
| V. Latest Developments and Concluding Remarks | 122 |