M&A and the simulation-based valuation of companies with an uncertain exit price and special rights
JOURNAL ARTICLE
Cite JOURNAL ARTICLE
Style
Format
M&A and the simulation-based valuation of companies with an uncertain exit price and special rights
Gleißner, Werner | Wolfrum, Marco | Dorfleitner, Gregor
Credit and Capital Markets – Kredit und Kapital, Online First : pp. 1–37
Additional Information
Article Details
Author Details
Prof. Dr. Werner Gleißner is a member of the board of the FutureValue Group AG and honorary professor for business administration, esp. risk management, at the TU Dresden. He is also a board member of the European Association of Certified Valuators and Analysts (EACVA).
Marco Wolfrum is a partner of FutureValue Group AG and deputy chairman of the board of the RMA Risk Management & Rating Association e.V. as well as managing director of the RMA Rating & Risk Academy GmbH. He is a lecturer in risk management at various universities.
Prof. Dr. Gregor Dorfleitner is Professor of Finance and Director of the Center of Finance at the University of Regensburg.
References
-
Alford, A. (1992): The Effect of the set of comparable firms on the accuracy of the price-earnings valuation-method, Journal of Accounting Research, 30, 94–108.
Google Scholar -
Baker, M./Ruback, R. (1999): Estimating Industry Multiples, working paper, Harvard Business School, available at https://www.hbs.edu/faculty/Pages/item.aspx?num=1435 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Beaton, N./Sawyer, J. (2019): Use of Monte Carlo Simulation. Simulations in Valuation, AIRA Journal, 32(2), 16–19.
Google Scholar -
Behm, G. (2003): Valuation of Innovative Companies, Josef Eul Verlag, Lohmar.
Google Scholar -
Berk, J./DeMarzo, P. (2023): Corporate Finance, Global Edition, Pearson, Harlow.
Google Scholar -
Bhojraj, S./Lee, C. M. C. (2002): Who Is My Peer? A Valuation-Based Approach to the Selection of Comparable Firms, Journal of Accounting Research, 40(2), 407–439.
Google Scholar -
Blitz, D. (2020): Factor Performance 2010–2019: A Lost Decade?, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3562242 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Bruner, R. F./Eades, K. M./Harris, R. S./Higgins, R. C. (1998): Best Practices in Estimating the Cost of Capital: Survey and Synthesis, Financial Practice and Education, No. 1, Spring/Sommer, 13–18.
Google Scholar -
Calhoun, G. (2020): Price and Value: A Guide to Equity Market Valuation Metrics, Apress, New York.
Google Scholar -
Campbell, J. Y./Shiller, R. J. (1998): Valuation Ratios and Long-Run Stock Market Outlook, Journal of Portfolio Management, 24(2), 11–26.
Google Scholar -
Cederburg, S./Stoughton, N. (2018): Discretionary NAVs, available at https://www.wu.ac.at/fileadmin/wu/d/i/finance/BBS-Papers/SS2019/20190515_STOUGHTON.pdf (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Chen, L./Pelger, M./Zhu, J. (2019): Deep Learning in Asset Pricing, 04.04.2019, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3350138 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Cheng, A./McNamara, R. (2000): The Valuation Accuracy of the Price-Earnings and Price-Book Benchmark Valuation Methods, Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 15, 349–370.
Google Scholar -
Chullen, A./Kaltenbrunner, H./Schwetzler, B. (2015): Does consistency improve accuracy in multiple-based valuation? Journal of Business Economics, August 2015, 85(6), 635–662.
Google Scholar -
Cochrane, J. H. (2011): Discount Rates: American Finance Association Presidential Address, Journal of Finance, 66, 1047–1108.
Google Scholar -
Coenenberg, A. G. (1970): Unternehmensbewertung mit Hilfe der Monte-Carlo-Simulation, Zeitschrift für Betriebswirtschaft, 40(12), 793–804.
Google Scholar -
Coulon, Y. (2022): Small Business Valuation Methods – How to Evaluate Small, Privately-Owned Businesses, palgrave macmillan, Cham CH.
Google Scholar -
Damodaran, A. (2011): The little Book of Valuation – How to value a Company, pick a stock and profit, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ.
Google Scholar -
Damodaran, A. (2018): Facing Up to Uncertainty: Using Probabilistic Approaches in Valuation, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3237778 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
DeAngelo, L. E. (1989): Equity valuation and corporate control, The Accounting Review, 65(1), 93–112.
Google Scholar -
Dorfleitner, G. (2022): On the use of the terminal-value approach in risk-value models, Annals of Operations Research, 313(2), 877–897.
Google Scholar -
Dorfleitner, G./Gleißner, W. (2018): Valuing streams of risky cashflows with risk-value models, Journal of Risk, 20(3), 1–27.
Google Scholar -
Elgammal, M./Ahmed, F./McMillan, D. G./Al-Amari, A. (2020): How many factors? Does adding momentum and volatility improve performance?, Journal of Business Accounting and Finance Perspectives, 2(1), 5ff.
Google Scholar -
Ernst, D. (2022a): Simulation-Based Business Valuation: Methodical Implementation in the Valuation Practice, Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 15(5), 200–217.
Google Scholar -
Ernst, D. (2022b): Simulationsbasierte Unternehmensbewertung, WiSt, 51(11), 16–23.
Google Scholar -
Ernst, D./Gleißner, W. (2022): Paradigm Shift in Finance: The Transformation of the Theory from Perfect to Imperfect Capital Markets Using the Example of Company Valuation, Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 15(9), 1–13, https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm15090399.
Google Scholar -
Ernst, D./Kamarás, E. (2023): Simulationsbasierte Unternehmensplanung und Unternehmensbewertung: Eine Fallstudie für eine praxisgerechte Umsetzung, Corporate Finance, 14(11–12), 282–292.
Google Scholar -
Fama, E. F. (1977): Risk-Adjusted Discount Rates and Capital Budgeting under Uncertainty, Journal of Financial Economics, 5, 3–24.
Google Scholar -
Fama, E. F./French, K. R. (1993): Common Risk Factors in the Returns on Stocks and Bonds, Journal of Financial Economics, 33(1), 3–56.
Google Scholar -
Fama, E. F./French, K. R. (2015): A Five-Factor Asset Pricing Model, Journal of Financial Economics, 116(1), 1–22.
Google Scholar -
Fama, E. F./French, K. R. (2018): Choosing factors, Journal of Financial Economics, 128(2), 234–252.
Google Scholar -
Follert, F. (2019): Zur Unternehmensbewertung im Spruchverfahren aus interessentheoretischer Sicht, Dissertation, Universität des Saarlandes.
Google Scholar -
Follert, F./Gleißner, W. (2024): A decision model to value football player investments under uncertainty, Management Decision, Vol. 62(13), 25.03.2024, available at https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/MD-06-2023-0899/full/html (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Follert, F./Herbener, J. M./Olbrich, M./Rapp, D. J. (2018): Agree or disagree? On the role of negotiations for the valuation of business enterprises, The Quarterly Journal of Austrian Economics, 21(4), 315–338.
Google Scholar -
Franken, L./Gleißner, W./Schulte, J. (2020): Insolvenzrisiko und Berücksichtigung des Verschuldungsgrads bei der Bewertung von Unternehmen – Stand der Diskussion nach Veröffentlichung des IDW Praxishinweises 2/2018, Corporate Finance, No. 3–4, 84–96.
Google Scholar -
Friedrich, T. (2016): Corporate valuation and risk of insolvency – Binomial models as a means to capture the effects of insolvency / Unternehmensbewertung und Insolvenzrisiko – Erfassung der Auswirkungen eines Insolvenz anhand von Binomialmodellen, Die Betriebswirtschaft, 76(6), 521–543.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W. (2010): Unternehmenswert, Rating und Risiko, Die Wirtschaftsprüfung, 63(14), 735–743.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W. (2011): Risikoanalyse und Replikation für Unternehmensbewertung und wertorientierte Unternehmenssteuerung, Wirtschaftswissenschaftliches Studium, No 7, 345–352.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W. (2019): Cost of capital and probability of default in value-based risk management, Management Research Review, 42(11), 1243–1258.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W. (2022): Grundlagen des Risikomanagements, Vahlen, München.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W. (2023): Finanzwirtschaft und Risiko – Finanzierung, Kapitalkostenberechnung und Investitionsbewertung mit Methoden des Risikomanagements, BFuP, 75(5), 598–619.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W./Ernst, D. (2019): Company valuation as result of risk analysis: replication approach as an alternative to the CAPM, Business Valuation OIV Journal, 1(1), 3–18.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W./Ernst, D. (2023): The Simulation-Based Valuation of Companies and Their Strategies – Classification, Methodology and Case Study, European Business Valuation Magazine, 2(2), 4–16.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W./Ernst, D. (2024): Neue Wege der Unternehmensbewertung – Der BGH-Beschluss zur Bestimmung der angemessenen Abfindung und seine Auswirkungen, BFuP, 76(4), 414–431.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W./Follert, F. (2022): Unternehmensbewertung im Spannungsfeld zwischen Zweckadäquanz und Praktikabilität: Ein Lösungsansatz für die gerichtliche Abfindungsbemessung, Betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung und Praxis, 74(4), 395–419.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W./Kamarás, E. (2023): Company Valuation Using the DCF Method and CAPM: You Shouldn’t Trust the Result, available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4396512 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W./Knoll, L./Spahlinger, T. (2024): Die in Praxis genutzten Verfahren der Unternehmensbewertung: Zwei Befragungen und die Bedeutung der simulationsbasierten Bewertung, Bewertungspraktiker, No. 3, 89–93.
Google Scholar -
Gleißner, W./Wolfrum, M. (2008): Simulationsbasierte Bewertung und Exit Preis-Schätzung bei PE-Gesellschaften, M&A-Review, No 7, 343–350.
Google Scholar -
Grabowski, R. J. (2018): The Size Effect Continues To Be Relevant When Estimating the Cost of Capital, Business Valuation Review, 37(3), 93–109.
Google Scholar -
Gromb, D./Vayanos, D. (2010): Limits of Arbitrage, Annual Review of Financial Economics, 2(1), 251–275.
Google Scholar -
Haugen, R. A. (2002): The Inefficient Stock Market – What Pays Off and Why, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ.
Google Scholar -
Hering, Th. (2000): Konzeptionen der Unternehmensbewertung und ihre Eignung für mittelständische Unternehmen, BFuP, 52(5), 433–453.
Google Scholar -
Hering, Th. (2021): Unternehmensbewertung, De Gruyter Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag, München.
Google Scholar -
Hering, Th./Schneider, J./Toll, Ch. (2013a): Simulative Unternehmensbewertung, Betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung und Praxis, 65(3), 256–280.
Google Scholar -
Hering, Th./Toll, Ch. (2013): Totalmodell zur Entscheidungswertermittlung, in Petersen, K./Zwirner, Ch./Brösel, G. (Eds.), Handbuch der Unternehmensbewertung, Köln, 173–183.
Google Scholar -
Hering, Th./Toll, Ch./Kirilova, P. (2013b): Decision-oriented business valuation in preparation for a company purchase, in Zarzecki, D. (Ed.), Proceedings of the 14th International Financial Management Conference 2013, Vol. I: Business Valuation, Value-Based Management, Risk Management, Stettin, 37–47.
Google Scholar -
Hering, Th./Toll, Ch./Kirilova, P. (2014): Acquiring a Company: Assessing the Maximum Affordable Price, World Review of Business Research, 4(3), 35–44.
Google Scholar -
Hering, Th./Toll, Ch./Schneider, J. (2012): Zur Bewertung einer Wagniskapitalbeteiligung aus Sicht eines jungen Wachstumsunternehmens, Betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung und Praxis, 64(3), 235–261.
Google Scholar -
Herrmann, V. (2002): Marktpreisschätzung mit kontrollierten Multiplikatoren, EUL Verlag, Lohmar.
Google Scholar -
Herrmann, V./Richter, F. (2003): Pricing with Performance-Controlled Multiples, Schmalenbach Business Review (sbr): 55(3), 194–219.
Google Scholar -
Hertz, D. B. (1964): Risk Analysis in Capital Investment, Harvard Business Review, 42(1), 95–106.
Google Scholar -
Hunziker, S. (2021): Enterprise Risk Management: Modern Approaches to Balancing Risk and Reward, 2nd ed., Springer Gabler, Wiesbaden.
Google Scholar -
Jegadeesh, N./Titman, S. (2011): Momentum, University of Texas and the NBER.
Google Scholar -
Jenkinson, T./Landsman, W. R./Rountree, B. R./Soonawalla, K. (2019): Private Equity Net Asset Values and Future Cash Flows, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2636985 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Joyce, C./Mayer, K. (2012): Profits for the Long Run: Affirming the Case for Quality, GMO White Paper.
Google Scholar -
Kaboth, J./Lodowicks, A./Schreiter, M./Schwetzler, B. (2022): Same same but different: how preferential claims trigger valuation discounts in equity tranches of VC‑backed firms, Review of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 23.11.2023, available at https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11156-022-01115-2 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Kahneman, D./Tversky, A. (1979): Prospect theory: An analysis of decisions under risk, Econometrica, 47(2), 313–327.
Google Scholar -
Kaplan, S./Ruback, R. S. (1996): The market pricing of Cash flow forecasts: Discounted Cash flow vs. the method of ‘comparables’, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, Winter, 45–60.
Google Scholar -
Kelleners, A. (2004): Risikoneutrale Unternehmensbewertung und Multiplikatoren, Springer, Wiesbaden.
Google Scholar -
Kerins, F./Smith, J. K./Smith, R. (2004): Opportunity Cost of Capital for Venture Capital Investors and Entrepreneurs, Journal of financial and quantitative analysis, 39(2), 385–405.
Google Scholar -
Khalkar, Sh./Mehta, N. (2020): Stock Valuation using Monte Carlo Simulation and Statistical Analysis, International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, 7(1), 1226–1233.
Google Scholar -
Klingelhöfer, H. E./Lerm, M./Mirschel, S. (2009): Bewertung von Stimmrechtsänderungen, Betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung und Praxis, 61(3), 302–321.
Google Scholar -
Klobucnik, J./Sievers, S. (2013): Valuing high technology growth firms, Journal of Business Economics, 83(9), 947–984.
Google Scholar -
Knabe, M. (2012): Die Berücksichtigung von Insolvenzrisiken in der Unternehmensbewertung, Josef Eul Verlag, Lohmar.
Google Scholar -
Kraus, A./Litzenberger, R. H. (1976): Skewness Preference and the Valuation of Risk Assets, The Journal of Finance, 31(4), 1085–1100.
Google Scholar -
Krolle, S./Schmitt, G./Schwetzler, B. (2005): Multiplikatorverfahren in der Unternehmensbewertung, Anwendungsbereiche, Problemfälle, Lösungsalternativen, Stuttgart.
Google Scholar -
Lahmann, A./Schreiter, M./Schwetzler, B. (2018): Der Einfluss von Insolvenz, Kapitalstruktur und Fremdkapitalfälligkeit auf den Unternehmenswert, Schmalenbachs Zeitschrift für betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung, 70(1–2), 73–123.
Google Scholar -
Lahmann, A./Schreiter, M./Schwetzler, B. (2019): Finanzierungspolitiken, Tax Shield und Insolvenz in der Unternehmensbewertung – ein integrativer Ansatz, Die Wirtschaftsprüfung, 72(6), 351–359.
Google Scholar -
Lauber, G. (2014): Das Verhältnis des Ausgleichs gemäß § 304 AktG zu den Abfindungen gemäß den §§ 305, 327 a AktG, LIT Verlag, Münster.
Google Scholar -
Leach, J. (2014): The correct understanding of the Business Judgment Rule in Section 76(4) of the Companies Act 71 of 2008: avoiding the American mistakes, University of Cape Town.
Google Scholar -
Liu, J./Nissim, D./Thomas, J. (2002): Equity Valuation Using Multiples, Journal of Accounting Research, 40(1), 135–172.
Google Scholar -
Matschke, M. J. (1972): Der Gesamtwert der Unternehmung als Entscheidungswert, Betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung und Praxis, 24(9), 146–161.
Google Scholar -
Matschke, M. J. (1975): Der Entscheidungswert der Unternehmung, Wiesbaden.
Google Scholar -
Matschke, M. J. (1979): Funktionale Unternehmensbewertung, Band II, Der Arbitriumwert der Unternehmung, Wiesbaden.
Google Scholar -
Matschke, M. J./Brösel, G. (2021): Business Valuation – Functions, Methods, Principles, utb, München.
Google Scholar -
Matschke, M./Brösel, G./Matschke, X. (2010): Fundamentals of functional business valuation, Journal of Business Valuation and Economic Loss Analysis, 5(1), 1–39.
Google Scholar -
Matschke, M./Brösel, G./Thielmann, P. (2020): Functional business valuation – The theoretical foundation of argumentation value and its underlying function, Managerial Economics, 21(2), 157–175.
Google Scholar -
Morris, J. R. (2009): Life and Death of Businesses: A Review of Research on Firm Mortality, Journal of Business Valuation and Economic Loss Analysis, 4(1), 1–39.
Google Scholar -
Müller, E. (2004): Underdiversification in Private Companies – Required Returns and Incentive Effects, ZEW Discussion Paper No. 04-29, Mannheim.
Google Scholar -
Oh, D./Cho, Y.-H. (2013): Validating the Technology Valuation with Monte Carlo Simulation, International Journal of Engineering Research and Applications, 3(1), 545–555.
Google Scholar -
Olbrich, M./Quill, T./Rapp, D. J. (2015): Business Valuation Inspired by the Austrian School, Journal of Business Valuation and Economic Loss Analysis, 10, 1–43.
Google Scholar -
Quill, T. (2020): Valuation Techniques Under Construction – About the Dissemination of the CAPM in German Judicial Valuation, Schmalenbach Business Review, 72, 299–341.
Google Scholar -
Richter, F. (2005): Mergers & Acquisitions: Investmentanalyse, Finanzierung und Prozessmanagement, Vahlen Verlag, München.
Google Scholar -
Roosenboom, P. (2012): Valuing and pricing IPOs, Journal of Banking & Finance, 36(6), 1653–1664.
Google Scholar -
Ross, S. A. (1976): The arbitrage theory of capital asset pricing, Journal of Economic Theory, 13(3), 341–360.
Google Scholar -
Saha, A./Malkiel, B. G. (2012): DCF Valuation with Cash Flow Cessation Risk, Journal of Applied Finance, 22(1), 175–185.
Google Scholar -
Schosser, J./Grottke, M. (2013): Nutzengestützte Unternehmensbewertung: Ein Abriss der jüngeren Literatur, Schmalenbachs Zeitschrift für betriebswirtschaftliche Forschung, 65, 306–341.
Google Scholar -
Schreiner, A. (2007): Equity Valuation Using Multiples – An Empirical Investigation, DUV, Wiesbaden.
Google Scholar -
Schüler, A. (2020): Valuation with Multiples: A Conceptual Analysis, Journal of Business Valuation and Economic Loss Analysis, 15(1), 13–25.
Google Scholar -
Schwartz, E. S./Moon, M. (2000): Rational Pricing of Internet Companies, Financial Analysts Journal, 56(3), 62–75.
Google Scholar -
Schwartz, E. S./Moon, M. (2001): Rational Pricing of Internet Companies Revisited, The Financial Review, 36(4), 7–26.
Google Scholar -
Shleifer, A./Vishny R. W. (1997): The Limits of Arbitrage, The Journal of Finance, 52(1), 35–55.
Google Scholar -
Swade, A./Hanauer, M./Lohre, H./Blitz, D. (2023): Factor Zoo (.zip), 18.10.2023, available at https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4605976 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar -
Timmreck, Ch. (2003): Unternehmensbewertung bei Mergers & Acquisitions, Hans Böckler Stiftung, No 93.
Google Scholar -
Ungemach, F./Hachmeister, D. (2019): Einsatz stochastischer Simulationen im Rahmen der Unternehmensbewertung, in: Ballwieser, W. and Hachmeister, D. (Ed.), Digitalisierung und Unternehmensbewertung. Neue Objekte, Prozesse, Parametergewinnung, Stuttgart, 193–220.
Google Scholar -
Vanini, U./Rieg, R. (2021): Risikomanagement: Grundlagen – Instrumente – Unternehmenspraxis, Schäffer Poeschel, Stuttgart.
Google Scholar -
Wieczorek, G./Nickert, C. (2023): Die Bayessche Statistik im Risikomanagement, BFuP, No. 5, 658ff.
Google Scholar -
Yoo, Y. K. (2006): The valuation accuracy of equity valuation using a combination of multiples, Review of Accounting and Finance, 5(2), 108–123.
Google Scholar -
Zhang, L. (2020): Q-Factors and Investment CAPM, Oxford University Press, available at https://doi.org/10.1093/acrefore/9780190625979.013.593 (accessed 10 October 2024).
Google Scholar
Abstract
This article presents a new methodological approach to value private equity investments based on simulation. The valuation relies on ‘imperfect replication’. This method does not presuppose the perfection of the capital market and is essentially built on measuring the risk. The approach turns out to be easy to implement. Firm specific characteristics as well as and existing special rights can be depicted and modelled. The proposed methodology is of immediate practical usefulness as it can help to find decision support for concrete investment situations. Also, during the investment period it can be used for monitoring. The originality of the research lies in the combination of Monte Carlo simulation, multiple methods, relevant risk measures and risk-value models.